Pielicious Bake Shoppe

Alice White makes genuinely homemade pies—she rolls the crust and fills them herself, each 10-inch pie packed with at least 4 cups of fruit. She operates under Florida's Cottage Food Law from a pet-free, smoke-free home kitchen, which means you're getting something you literally cannot buy at a commercial bakery. Order early enough and you might have it the same afternoon.

Call or order early in the day if you want same-day pickup; otherwise plan ahead with a day's notice. Holiday season if you want 6-inch mini pies for gift trays.

She'll personalize pies and gift-wrap them, and takes custom requests including sugar-free versions and wedding pies—ask what's possible.

Wayfind is an independent guide, not affiliated with the places listed. Details come from Google and may change — confirm hours before you go.