Madison Avenue Pizza

Madison Avenue Pizza does the fundamentals right—dough made daily, a full menu beyond pizza (calzones, strombolis, wings), and a bar setup that actually works for watching games or lingering with a beer. It's the kind of place that accumulates regulars because it doesn't pretend to be anything fancier than it is. If you're on Bayshore near Honeymoon Island and want to eat well without ceremony, this is the move.

Friday or Saturday evening if you want the bar energy and don't mind a crowd; Wednesday–Thursday lunch if you want to move fast and actually get a table without waiting.

Order slices if you're passing through—they serve them all day, so you don't need to commit to a whole pie if you're just hungry and mobile.

Featured by @tampaterrencee, @eatsbylaurr

Wayfind is an independent guide, not affiliated with the places listed. Details come from Google and may change — confirm hours before you go.