Der Dutchman
The bigger Amish kitchen up the street: broasted chicken, a bakery the size of a gift shop, and breakfast that ends any diet.
Read the full Pinecraft: Inside Sarasota's Amish Village (And Yoder's Famous Pie) →Map & parking
Its Amish-Mennonite comfort-food buffet — broasted chicken, mashed potatoes, noodles, and dressing — with an on-site bakery famous for cinnamon rolls and pies.
A big, busy Amish-Mennonite buffet in Pinecraft — broasted chicken, real mashed potatoes, noodles, and an on-site bakery stacked with cinnamon rolls and pies. Hearty, family-style, closed Sundays.
Food: Load up on the broasted (pressure-fried) chicken from the buffet ($$), then hit the bakery for a cinnamon roll or a whole pie.
More Restaurants in Sarasota ›
Nearby on Wayfind
Lucky 8food ›Indigenous Restaurantfood ›Focaccia Sandwich + Bakeryfood ›Sage Restaurantfood ›Blu Kouzina UTCfood ›Florence and the Spice Boysfood ›Own Der Dutchman? Get your free Top Rated badge ›
Wayfind is an independent guide, not affiliated with the places listed. Details come from Google and may change — confirm hours before you go.