What to Eat Near Tampa BayItalian
The best Italian near Tampa Bay
71 places · ranked by real reviews, not adsThe shortlist is already built
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4RestaurantDue Amici Pizza & Pasta BarHand-stretched pizza and scratch pasta on 7th Avenue in Ybor City@tampaterrenceeInstagram
- 5RestaurantPia's Trattoria
- 6RestaurantSlice of The Burg
- 7RestaurantLa Terrazza Restaurant
- 8RestaurantJay Luigi
- 9RestaurantChanta
- 10RestaurantOsteria Natalina
- 11RestaurantBella Roma NY Pizza
- 12RestaurantOriginal Flavor 1889
- 13RestaurantNoble Crust of St. Petersburg
- 14RestaurantCasa Santo StefanoHoused in a 1925 Ybor City macaroni factory, this is Tampa Sicilian food—not the Sicily version
- 15RestaurantOLIVIA
- 16RestaurantJoey Brooklyn's Famous Pizza Kitchen
- 17RestaurantBella's Italian Cafe
- 18RestaurantValentino Ristorante Italiano
- 19RestaurantEsposito's Italian Restaurant And Bar
- 20RestaurantWater + Flour
- 21RestaurantChef Tony Macaroni & Co.
- 22RestaurantThe Vineyards Trattoria and Pizzeria
- 23RestaurantMandola's Italian Kitchen
- 24
- 25RestaurantPiccolo Buco by Coopers HawkNeapolitan pizza with a crust so tall@secretsoftampabayInstagram
- 26RestaurantOsteria Pollani
- 27RestaurantBellaBrava - St. Petersburg
- 28RestaurantThe Sacred Pepper
- 29RestaurantMandola's Italian Kitchen
- 30RestaurantNoble Crust Of CarrollwoodA place that treats pizza and biscuits as equally serious pursuits
- 31RestaurantFrankie's Italian DeliAuthentic Italian market and deli foods, from sandwiches to Sicilian street food@tampaterrenceeInstagram
- 32RestaurantGratzzi Italian Grille
- 33
- 34
- 35RestaurantStreet Crust
- 36RestaurantChe Vita
- 37RestaurantDonatello Italian RestaurantTuxedos, live jazz, and hand-made pasta daily—this is old-school Italian done right
- 38RestaurantBravo NY Pizzeria
- 39RestaurantMandola’s Italian Kitchen
- 40RestaurantAllegria Italiana
- 41RestaurantCarino's Northern Italian Cuisine
- 42RestaurantIl Ritorno
- 43RestaurantOLIVIAModern Italian trattoria with a working dough room making pasta and ravioli@cailincoastalInstagram
- 44RestaurantTaverna CostaleChef Fabio Viviani's St. Pete outpost nails the hardest thing: making fresh pasta
- 45RestaurantBeccofino Italian BistroThis is Tuscan cooking stripped to its essentials—no shortcuts, no authenticity theater@influencetampaInstagram
- 46RestaurantJay LuigiFresh pasta and naturally fermented Roman-style and Neapolitan-style pizzas in SoHo@tampaterrenceeInstagram
- 47RestaurantGUSTO Italian Restaurant
- 48RestaurantThe Last Slice
- 49RestaurantMassimo's Eclectic Fine Dining
- 50RestaurantCirco Italian Kitchen
- 51RestaurantCaffé Paradiso
- 52RestaurantKinjo
- 53RestaurantDa Sesto Italiano Ristorante e Vino
- 54RestaurantV Modern ItalianModern Italian in Tampa with house-made pastas, hand-crafted pizzas, and chef Stefano Ciotti dishes@tastetravelunravelInstagram
- 55RestaurantLa Dolce Vita Trattoria - Clearwater
- 56
- 57RestaurantBonu' Taverna Italiana
- 58RestaurantPia’s Veranda
- 59RestaurantSpartaco's Kitchen
- 60RestaurantPositano Ristorante Italiano by Bachi's
- 61RestaurantFlor Fina
- 62RestaurantGiovanni's Fresh Italian Kitchen
- 63RestaurantTony's Pizza
- 64RestaurantHerb And Oven
- 65RestaurantCarmine's Restaurant & Bar - YborCarmine's deviled crab is the real thing—a Tampa institution that doesn't pretend to be anything
- 66RestaurantGiancarlo’sTampa Italian spot serving brunch, dinner, and dessert with pizza and classic entrees@sidebaratgsInstagram
- 67RestaurantSouth Shore Pizza & Subs
- 68RestaurantBasilico Pizzeria Riverview FL
- 69RestaurantThe Brother Trattoria
- 70RestaurantTuscan Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
- 71RestaurantVillaggio's Ristorante Italiano
Eat your way around it
via ViatorGuided food tours near here — someone else picks the stops.
No paid placement. No sponsored rankings. Order comes from real reviews and our own signal — a place can never pay to move up.